Potting mix vs garden soil: what to use in pots and beds
Bags in a garden center can say potting soil, potting mix, container mix, garden soil, topsoil, raised bed mix or seed-starting mix. They are not interchangeable. The key difference is whether the product is made to work in a container or in the ground.
Why garden soil does not work in pots
In the ground, water drains away through the soil below. In a pot, it cannot: water collects in a saturated layer at the bottom of the container. Garden soil in a pot packs down, holds too much of that water, and leaves roots short of air. Plants in it often wilt, yellow or rot even when watered correctly. It can also bring in weed seeds, insects and disease.
Potting mix is made for this. It is light, it holds water while leaving air spaces, and it does not compact as quickly.
What is in a bag
| Product | Typical contents | Use it for |
|---|---|---|
| Potting mix (often sold as potting soil) | Peat moss or coir, composted bark, perlite or vermiculite, lime, often a wetting agent and starter fertilizer. Usually little or no real soil. | Pots, window boxes, hanging baskets, houseplants |
| Seed-starting mix | Fine peat or coir with vermiculite or perlite, low in nutrients | Sowing seeds in trays and cells |
| Cactus and succulent mix | Potting mix with more grit, sand or perlite | Plants that need sharp drainage |
| Orchid mix | Chunky bark, sometimes charcoal or sphagnum | Epiphytic orchids |
| Garden soil or garden mix | Topsoil blended with compost or other organic matter | Mixing into in-ground beds |
| Topsoil | Screened mineral soil, quality varies widely | Filling low spots, the base of a deep raised bed |
| Raised bed mix | Topsoil and compost, sometimes with bark or perlite | Filling raised beds |
Read the bag rather than trusting the name. "Potting soil" is a common label for what is really a soilless potting mix.
Choosing a mix
- Vegetables, annuals and herbs in pots: a general potting mix. Larger pots dry out more slowly and are easier to manage; see container gardening basics for pot sizes.
- Seeds: seed-starting mix. It is fine and low in fertilizer, which suits tiny seedlings. Move them to potting mix when they have their first true leaves or are ready for a larger pot.
- Succulents and cacti: a cactus mix, or general mix with extra perlite.
- Raised beds: a raised bed mix, or a blend of good topsoil and compost. Filling a large bed with bagged potting mix is costly and it settles a lot. See how to build a raised bed for fill options.
- In-ground beds: improve the soil you have with compost rather than replacing it.
Making your own blend
A common home blend is roughly equal parts peat moss or coir, perlite or vermiculite, and screened, finished compost. Peat is acidic, so commercial mixes add lime to balance it. A home blend has no starter fertilizer unless you add one, so plan to feed sooner.
Wet it before you use it
Peat-based mix that has dried out repels water at first. Moisten it in a tub or wheelbarrow, mixing until it feels like a wrung-out sponge, before you fill pots. If a dried-out pot sheds water down the sides, set it in a tray of water for 20 to 30 minutes so it soaks up from below.
Feeding plants in potting mix
Potting mix holds only a small store of nutrients, and frequent watering washes them out. A mix with starter fertilizer usually feeds plants for a few weeks to a few months, as the bag states. After that, feed with a liquid fertilizer or a slow-release fertilizer at the rate and interval on the label. Hungry plants show pale or yellowing older leaves and slow growth.
Drainage: holes, not gravel
Every container needs drainage holes. Do not put a layer of gravel or broken pots in the bottom. Extension research shows it does not improve drainage: the saturated layer simply moves up into the mix above the gravel, and the gravel takes up root space. If a pot stays too wet, use a coarser mix or a deeper pot, and empty saucers after watering.
Reusing potting mix
- Mix from healthy plants can be reused. Pull out old roots, loosen it, and mix in about one part fresh potting mix or compost to two or three parts old mix.
- Do not reuse mix from plants that had root rot, wilt diseases, or heavy pest problems. Add it to an in-ground bed away from the same plant family, or bag it for the trash.
- Old mix breaks down and holds more water each year. Replace it entirely in long-term containers every few years.
Common problems
- Fungus gnats: small black flies around houseplants mean the mix stays too wet. Let the top inch (2.5 cm) dry between waterings.
- White crust on top: fertilizer salts. Water heavily so it runs out the bottom, and scrape off the crust.
- Mix shrinking from the pot sides: it has dried out. Soak from below as above.
- Mushrooms in a pot: harmless to the plant but not to be eaten. Pick them off and bin them where children or pets could reach them.
Handle bags safely
Bagged potting mix and compost can carry Legionella bacteria, which cause a lung infection if breathed in. Open bags slowly and away from your face, dampen dusty mix before you handle it, and wash your hands afterwards, even if you wore gloves. Keep opened bags closed between uses.