How to improve garden soil, starting with a soil test
Most soil problems come down to four things: the wrong pH, too little organic matter, poor drainage, or compaction. You cannot tell which by looking, so the first step is a soil test. Then you add what is missing, and only that.
Step 1: Get a soil test
A basic test reports pH and the main nutrients (phosphorus, potassium, often calcium and magnesium), usually with a recommendation for lime or fertilizer. Many university extension services run tests for home gardeners or can point you to a lab. Home kits give a rough pH reading but are less reliable for nutrients.
How to take a sample
- Use a clean trowel and a clean plastic bucket (metal can affect the results).
- Take 10 to 15 small slices from around the bed or area, avoiding odd spots such as old compost heaps or where a bag of fertilizer spilled.
- Dig each slice to about 6 inches (15 cm) deep for vegetable and flower beds, or about 3 to 4 inches (8 to 10 cm) for lawns.
- Remove stones, roots and mulch, mix the slices in the bucket, and send the amount the lab asks for.
- Sample vegetable beds, lawns and ornamental beds separately, since they are managed differently.
Test every 3 to 5 years, or sooner if plants struggle. Fall is a good time: results arrive before spring, and lime has time to work.
Step 2: Know your soil texture
Texture is the mix of sand, silt and clay, and you cannot change it much. What you can change is how the soil behaves, by adding organic matter.
| Texture | Feel when moist | Strengths | Problems |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sandy | Gritty, will not hold a shape | Drains fast, warms early in spring | Dries out quickly, nutrients wash through |
| Loam | Holds a shape, crumbles when poked | Balance of drainage and moisture | Few; keep adding organic matter |
| Clay | Sticky, rolls into a long ribbon | Holds water and nutrients well | Slow to drain and warm, easily compacted |
A simple jar test gives a rough idea: half fill a straight-sided jar with soil, top up with water, shake hard and let it settle. Sand drops within a minute or two, silt over a few hours, and clay can take a day or more to settle. The thickness of each layer shows the rough mix.
Do not add sand to clay to "lighten" it. Unless you add a very large amount, the mix can end up denser than either. Organic matter is the fix for both sandy and clay soils.
Step 3: Check drainage
Dig a hole about 12 inches (30 cm) deep and fill it with water. Let it drain, then refill it and measure how far the water drops each hour. About 1 to 2 inches (2.5 to 5 cm) per hour suits most garden plants. Much slower means the site stays wet: choose plants that tolerate wet roots, or grow in raised beds. Much faster means sandy soil that needs more organic matter and more frequent watering. Test a few spots, since drainage can vary across one yard.
In the US, call 811 (or use your state's online 811 request) a few working days before any deep digging, such as a new bed, a tree or a drainage trench, so buried utility lines are marked. Notice periods vary by state; other countries have their own services.
Step 4: Add organic matter
Compost is the most useful thing you can add to almost any soil. In sand it holds water and nutrients; in clay it opens up the structure so water and roots move through.
- New bed: spread 2 to 3 inches (5 to 8 cm) of compost and work it into the top 6 to 8 inches (15 to 20 cm).
- Established bed: top-dress with about 1/2 to 1 inch (1 to 2.5 cm) of compost each year, or use it as part of your mulch.
- Other sources: shredded leaves, leaf mold, well-rotted manure and cover crops all add organic matter.
More is not always better. Years of heavy compost and manure can push phosphorus far above what plants need; a soil test will show this, and then you can switch to leaves or other low-nutrient material.
To make your own, see how to make compost at home. To work out how much compost or mulch to buy for a bed, use the mulch calculator, which also works for compost depth.
Step 5: Adjust pH only if the test says so
Most vegetables, flowers and lawns grow well in soil with a pH of about 6.0 to 7.0. Some plants want more acid soil: blueberries do best at about 4.5 to 5.5, and rhododendrons and azaleas also prefer acid soil.
- To raise pH (make soil less acid), add garden lime at the rate your soil test gives.
- To lower pH, add elemental sulfur at the rate your soil test gives.
Both work slowly, over months, and adding either without a test can push pH the wrong way. Wood ash also raises pH, so use it sparingly and not at all where the soil is already neutral or alkaline.
Step 6: Fertilize to the test
The test tells you which nutrients are short. Apply fertilizer at the rate the report or the product label gives, and no more. Excess fertilizer is wasted, can burn roots, and washes into streams. Blood, bone and fish meal fertilizers smell attractive to dogs and can make them ill if eaten, so work them into the soil and store the bags out of reach.
Step 7: Protect the structure
- Do not work wet soil. Squeeze a handful: if it stays in a sticky ball, wait. If it crumbles when poked, it is ready.
- Do not walk on beds. Make beds narrow enough to reach the center from a path, about 4 feet (1.2 m) wide when you can reach from both sides.
- Keep the soil covered. Mulch in summer and a cover crop such as cereal rye, oats or clover over winter protect against crusting and erosion. Turn cover crops under 2 to 3 weeks before planting.
- Dig less. Repeated tilling breaks down structure and brings weed seeds to the surface. Once a bed is established, adding compost on top is usually enough.
Manure, compost and hygiene
- Use composted or well-aged manure on food crops, not fresh manure. If raw manure is used, the USDA National Organic Program standard requires at least 120 days between application and harvest for crops whose edible part touches the soil, and 90 days for crops that do not.
- Some manure, hay, straw and compost carry persistent herbicide residues (such as aminopyralid or clopyralid) that survive composting and twist and stunt tomatoes, beans, peas, peppers and potatoes. Ask your supplier what the animals grazed or ate. If unsure, grow a few bean seedlings in a 50:50 mix of the material and potting mix next to a pot of plain potting mix and compare.
- Wear gloves for soil, compost and manure, and wash your hands afterwards. Soil can carry tetanus bacteria: clean any cut or puncture, and ask your doctor whether your tetanus vaccination is up to date.
- Bagged compost and potting mix can carry Legionella bacteria. Open bags away from your face, dampen dusty material, and wash your hands after handling it.
- Wash vegetables before eating them.
How to tell it is working
Improving soil takes a few seasons. Signs it is getting better: water soaks in instead of pooling or running off, the soil crumbles in your hand, you find more earthworms, it is easier to dig, and plants grow evenly without heavy feeding. Retest every few years to see how pH and nutrients have moved.