How to make compost at home: bins, browns and greens, problems
Compost is organic material that bacteria, fungi, worms and insects have broken down into a dark, crumbly soil improver. Every heap does this eventually. What you control is how fast, how well, and whether it smells or draws animals.
Choose a bin or heap
| Type | Good for | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Open heap | Large gardens with lots of leaves and trimmings | Cheapest; untidy, and not suitable for food scraps where animals roam |
| Wire or mesh hoop | Leaves and garden waste | Easy to build and lift off for turning |
| Closed plastic bin with lid | Small yards, kitchen scraps | Keeps out most animals and rain; slower to turn |
| Tumbler | Small amounts, easy turning | Each batch must finish before you add more |
| Two or three bays (wood or pallets) | Steady supply of finished compost | Fill one bay, turn it into the next, use from the last |
| Worm bin | Kitchen scraps in apartments or small spaces | Uses red wiggler worms; keep it out of frost and hot sun |
Put the bin on level, well-drained ground, within easy reach of the kitchen and a hose. Sitting it on bare soil lets worms move in. Where rats or other rodents are a problem, set it on a base of 1/4 inch (6 mm) galvanized hardware cloth and keep the lid closed.
Browns and greens
A heap needs two kinds of material. Greens are moist and rich in nitrogen; browns are dry and rich in carbon. Too many greens and the heap goes slimy and smells. Too many browns and it sits for a year doing little.
| Greens (nitrogen) | Browns (carbon) |
|---|---|
| Fruit and vegetable scraps | Dry leaves (shredded break down faster) |
| Coffee grounds and paper filters, tea leaves | Straw (not hay, which carries seeds) |
| Fresh grass clippings, in thin layers | Plain cardboard and newspaper, torn up |
| Green plant trimmings and spent annuals | Small twigs and woody stems, chopped |
| Manure from plant-eating animals (chickens, rabbits, horses, cows) | Sawdust or wood shavings from untreated wood |
A workable starting point is roughly two to three parts browns to one part greens by volume. It is a guide, not a formula: adjust by how the heap looks and smells. Keep a bag of dry leaves next to the bin so you can cover each load of kitchen scraps.
What not to compost at home
- Meat, fish, bones, dairy, fats and oils: they smell and attract rats, raccoons and dogs.
- Dog and cat waste, and used cat litter: they can carry parasites and disease.
- Diseased or pest-ridden plants, and weeds that have set seed or spread by roots (such as bindweed): home heaps rarely get hot enough throughout to kill them.
- Coal or charcoal ash, treated or painted wood, glossy or plastic-coated paper.
- Grass clippings from a lawn recently treated with herbicide. Some herbicide labels say not to compost the clippings; check the label.
- Wood ash only in small amounts, since it raises soil pH.
Step by step
- Start with a coarse layer. A few inches of twigs or straw at the base lets air in.
- Add materials in layers or mixed. Bury fresh kitchen scraps in the center and cover them with browns.
- Keep it as damp as a wrung-out sponge. Squeeze a handful: a drop or two of water is right. Water a dry heap as you add to it; cover a soggy one and add browns.
- Chop large material. Smaller pieces break down far faster.
- Turn it. Forking the outside to the middle every week or two adds air and speeds things up. An unturned heap still composts, only more slowly.
Hot and cold composting
A hot heap builds up to about 130 to 160 F (54 to 71 C) in the center. It needs a volume of at least about 3 by 3 by 3 feet (1 m cubed) built in one go, a good mix of browns and greens, moisture and regular turning. A hot heap can be ready in two to three months. Check it with a long compost thermometer, or feel for warmth in the middle.
A cold heap is one you add to bit by bit. It never gets very hot, needs little work, and takes six months to a year or more. Because it does not heat through, keep diseased plants and seeding weeds out of it.
Fixing problems
| Problem | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Smells of ammonia | Too many greens | Mix in browns |
| Smells rotten, slimy | Too wet, not enough air | Turn it, add dry browns, cover from rain |
| Not heating, nothing happening | Too dry, too small, or too many browns | Water, add greens, build a bigger heap |
| Warm in the middle only | Heap is small or outside is cold | Normal; turn the outside to the middle |
| Rats, raccoons or dogs getting in | Food scraps exposed, or meat or dairy added | Bury scraps under browns, use a closed bin on hardware cloth, stop adding meat and dairy |
| Fruit flies | Exposed scraps | Cover each load with browns |
| Ants | Heap too dry | Water and turn |
When it is ready, and how to use it
Finished compost is dark, crumbly and smells like earth. You should not recognize most of what went in. Let it sit for a few weeks after it cools to finish curing, then sieve out any lumps and return them to the next heap.
- Work 2 to 3 inches (5 to 8 cm) into a new bed, or top-dress established beds with about 1/2 to 1 inch (1 to 2.5 cm) a year. See how to improve garden soil.
- Spread it as a mulch around perennials and shrubs. The mulch calculator works out how much you need for an area and depth.
- Mix up to about a quarter or a third into homemade potting blends; see potting mix vs garden soil.
Safety and hygiene
- Wear gloves when you handle compost and manure, and wash your hands afterwards. Soil and compost can carry tetanus bacteria: clean any cut, and ask your doctor whether your tetanus vaccination is up to date.
- Bagged compost and potting mix can carry Legionella bacteria. Open bags away from your face, dampen dry, dusty compost before turning or sieving it, and wash your hands afterwards.
- Moldy food in a compost heap can contain molds that cause tremors and seizures in dogs that eat it. Keep bins closed and out of reach of pets. If a pet may have eaten from the heap, call your vet or a pet poison line now (in the US, the ASPCA Animal Poison Control Center at 888-426-4435 or the Pet Poison Helpline at 855-764-7661; both charge a fee).
- Use only composted, not fresh, manure on food crops, and wash produce before eating. Manure and hay from animals fed on treated pasture can carry persistent herbicides that harm tomatoes, beans and peppers even after composting, so ask the supplier.
- Mushrooms often appear on compost heaps. Do not eat them; remove them where children or dogs play.