Choosing pruners: bypass, anvil and when you need loppers
Hand pruners, called secateurs in the UK and elsewhere, are the tool most gardeners use more than any other. The right type makes clean cuts that the plant seals over quickly; the wrong one crushes stems, tires your hand and invites disease. What matters is the cutting mechanism, the size of stem you need to cut and how the tool fits your hand, not the brand.
Bypass pruners
Bypass pruners work like scissors: a sharp, curved cutting blade slides past a thicker, hooked lower blade. Because the cutting blade passes the stem rather than pressing it against a flat surface, the cut is clean and can be made close to a bud or branch.
- Best for: live, green stems: pruning shrubs and roses, deadheading, cutting flowers, harvesting vegetables and herbs.
- Limits: dry, dead wood is hard and can push the blades apart. Twisting the pruners to force a cut springs the blades and spoils the cut.
- Verdict: if you buy one pair, buy bypass pruners. Most extension guidance prefers them for general pruning.
Anvil pruners
Anvil pruners have a single straight blade that closes down onto a flat surface (the anvil), like a knife on a cutting board.
- Best for: dead, dry and hard woody stems, which they cut with less effort and less jamming than bypass pruners.
- Limits: they squeeze as they cut, so on soft, live stems they tend to crush the tissue on either side of the cut, and they cannot cut as close to a bud. A dull blade or worn anvil makes the crushing worse.
- Verdict: a useful second pair if you cut a lot of dead wood; not a first choice for live plants.
Ratchet and geared pruners
Ratchet pruners cut in stages: you squeeze, release and squeeze again, and the mechanism advances the blade each time. Geared or compound-action pruners use extra leverage to multiply hand strength in a single squeeze. Most ratchet models use an anvil-style blade.
- Best for: gardeners with reduced hand strength, small hands, or arthritis, and for thicker stems that would otherwise need a two-handed effort.
- Limits: slower for lots of small cuts, and the anvil types share the crushing drawback on live stems.
When pruners are not enough
Hand pruners are designed for stems up to about the thickness of a finger; most makers rate them for roughly 1/2 to 3/4 inch (12 to 20 mm), and the rating is printed on the tool or packaging. If you have to strain, twist or use two hands, move up a tool.
| Tool | Typical stem size | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Hand pruners | Up to about 3/4 inch (20 mm), often less | One-handed; for most routine cuts |
| Loppers | Roughly 1 to 2 inches (2.5 to 5 cm), depending on the model | Long handles give leverage and reach into the middle of a shrub. Available in bypass, anvil and ratchet versions, with the same strengths as hand pruners. |
| Pruning saw | Branches thicker than loppers can handle comfortably, roughly 1.5 inches (4 cm) and up | A folding saw fits in a pocket; many pruning saws are designed to cut on the pull stroke. Cleaner on thick wood than forcing loppers. |
| Hedge shears | Soft, thin shoots | For shaping formal hedges and small-leaved shrubs, not for cutting individual thick stems |
| Floral snips | Soft stems | Light, fine-tipped; good for deadheading, herbs and cutting flowers |
Pole pruners and pole saws extend reach for high branches from the ground. Branches that need a ladder, large limbs, chainsaw work and anything near power lines are jobs for a certified arborist. Never use any pole tool near overhead power lines.
Choosing a pair that fits
- Hand size. Pruners come in small, medium and large. With the handles fully open, you should be able to close them comfortably without stretching your fingers. Pruners that open too wide for your hand are tiring and hard to control.
- Left-handed models. Left-handed pruners are made with the blades reversed so you can see the cutting blade, and the lock on the correct side.
- Weight. Lighter tools are less tiring over a long session; heavier, forged ones are often more durable.
- Grip and handles. Cushioned or contoured grips spread the pressure. Some models have a rotating lower handle that turns with your fingers to reduce strain on long jobs.
- Lock. Check that you can work the safety lock easily with the hand holding the pruners, and that it does not engage by accident mid-cut.
- Serviceability. Pruners that come apart with a wrench, with replaceable blades and springs, can be sharpened properly and repaired for many years.
- Try before you buy where you can, holding them the way you would in use.
How to make a clean cut
- Use the right tool for the stem size. Cut as deep into the jaws as possible, close to the pivot, where the leverage is greatest.
- Position the blade. With bypass pruners, put the sharp cutting blade on the side of the plant that is staying, so any bruising from the hooked blade falls on the piece you are removing.
- Cut in the right place. When shortening a stem, cut about 1/4 inch (6 mm) above an outward-facing bud, sloping slightly away from it. When removing a branch, cut just outside the slightly swollen collar where it joins the larger stem, without leaving a stub.
- Do not twist. If the cut does not close with a steady squeeze, the stem is too thick. Twisting tears bark and springs the blades.
- Clean between plants when you are cutting out diseased wood, so you do not carry disease to healthy plants.
For when and where to prune particular plants, see how to prune shrubs and hedges.
Keeping pruners working
Wipe the blades after each use, remove sap, keep the cutting edge sharp, oil the pivot and store them dry. Sharp pruners cut cleanly and need less hand pressure. The full routine, including sharpening the bevel correctly, is in how to clean, sharpen and store garden tools.
Safety
- Keep the lock on and the blades closed whenever you are not cutting, and store pruners out of reach of children.
- Keep your other hand clear of the blades; hold the stem below the cut, not beside it.
- Wear gloves, especially with roses and thorny shrubs. Clean any cut or puncture and ask your doctor whether your tetanus vaccination is up to date.
- Wear eye protection when cutting at or above head height and when sawing, since twigs spring back.