How hydroponics works at home, and the problems to avoid
Hydroponics means growing plants with their roots in a water-based nutrient solution instead of soil. The solution supplies every nutrient the plant needs, and the system has to supply the other thing soil normally provides: air around the roots. Home systems range from a jar on a windowsill to a shelf of trays with pumps and timers. They all work on the same few principles, and most failures come from the same few problems.
What a hydroponic system needs
- Water and a complete hydroponic nutrient. Soil fertilizers are not a substitute: hydroponic nutrients are formulated to supply every element, including the calcium, magnesium and trace elements soil would otherwise provide. Mix them at the strength on the label.
- Oxygen at the roots. Roots sitting in still, airless water die. Each system below solves this differently.
- Support. Plants sit in net pots filled with an inert growing medium such as rockwool cubes, expanded clay pebbles or coco coir, which holds them upright without feeding them.
- Light. Indoors, almost always a grow light. Leafy greens and herbs need far more light than a windowsill gives in winter, and fruiting crops need more still.
The four systems home growers use
| System | How it works | Good for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kratky | A plant in a net pot sits over a container of nutrient solution with its roots in the liquid. No pump. As the plant drinks, the level drops and leaves an air gap, and the upper roots take in oxygen from it. | Lettuce, leafy greens and herbs; first experiments | Do not refill to the top, which drowns the air roots. Not well suited to large, thirsty fruiting plants. |
| Deep water culture (DWC) | Roots hang in a reservoir of solution that an air pump and air stone bubble constantly. | Leafy greens, herbs, and larger plants in bigger buckets | If the air pump stops, roots can suffer quickly. Warm water holds less oxygen. |
| Nutrient film technique (NFT) | A pump runs a thin film of solution along sloped channels; roots sit in the shallow flow with air above. | Lettuce and other quick, light crops | A pump failure or blocked channel can dry roots out within hours. |
| Ebb and flow (flood and drain) | A timer floods a tray of plants in medium, then lets it drain back to the reservoir, pulling in fresh air. | A mixed range of plants, including some fruiting crops | Timers, fittings and overflows need checking; a stuck drain floods roots. |
For a first try, a kratky jar or a small DWC bucket with lettuce or basil teaches the basics with little equipment. Leafy greens and herbs are the easiest crops; tomatoes, peppers and cucumbers can be grown but need more light, more space, support and pollination help indoors.
Running a system: pH, nutrient strength and water
Two measurements matter most, and an inexpensive pH meter or test kit and an EC (electrical conductivity) or TDS meter are worth having from the start.
- pH: most hydroponic crops do best with the solution at about pH 5.5 to 6.5. Outside that range, some nutrients become unavailable even though they are in the water. Adjust with pH up or pH down solutions, a little at a time, mixing and retesting after each addition.
- Nutrient strength (EC): this tells you how concentrated the solution is. Follow the nutrient maker's chart for your crop and growth stage; seedlings need a weaker solution than mature plants. Leafy greens are usually grown at the lower end of the range.
- Water temperature: aim for about 68 to 72°F (20 to 22°C). Warmer water holds less dissolved oxygen and favors root rot organisms.
- Topping up and changing: top up with plain water or weak solution as plants drink, and check pH and EC after topping up. Replace the whole solution periodically, and immediately if roots look unhealthy or the solution smells bad or turns cloudy. Clean and rinse the reservoir between crops.
Problems to avoid
Root rot
Healthy roots are white or cream and firm. Brown, slimy roots that smell bad mean root rot, often caused by water molds such as Pythium. It usually follows warm water, poor aeration or a dirty system. Keep the solution cool, keep air pumps running, keep light out of the reservoir and clean equipment between crops. Remove badly affected plants and start again with a cleaned system rather than trying to rescue them.
Algae
Green slime in the reservoir or channels competes for nutrients and oxygen and clogs pumps. Algae needs light: use opaque reservoirs and lids, cover gaps around net pots, and do not use clear containers without wrapping them.
Nutrient problems
Yellowing, pale new growth or brown leaf edges often trace back to pH drifting out of range or the solution being too weak or too strong. Check pH and EC before adding more nutrient. Brown, burned leaf tips on lettuce can also be tipburn, which is linked to fast growth, high light and poor air movement; a small fan helps.
Equipment failure
In pumped systems, a failed pump or a power cut can kill plants within hours in hot weather. Check systems daily, keep spare air stones and tubing, and listen for the pump.
Not enough light
Leggy, pale plants with long gaps between leaves need more light. The grow light calculator helps you size a light for your growing area, and how much light plants need indoors explains distance and timing.
Pests
Indoor systems are not pest-free. Aphids, spider mites, thrips and fungus gnats all turn up. Inspect leaf undersides weekly, remove infested leaves and rinse plants. Any pesticide, including insecticidal soap or neem oil, must be labeled for indoor use on that crop and used exactly as the label directs, including the pre-harvest interval for food crops. Do not add homemade mixtures to a hydroponic system.
Safety
- Water and electricity. Plug pumps and lights into a GFCI (RCD) protected outlet. Give every cord a drip loop (a dip below the outlet) so water runs off before reaching the plug. Keep power strips, timers and plugs off the floor and above any possible spill or overflow.
- pH up and pH down are a base and an acid. Wear gloves and eye protection when handling them, add them to water rather than water to them, keep them in their original labeled containers and store them, and concentrated nutrients, out of reach of children and pets.
- Lights. Follow the fixture's clearance recommendations and keep hot lamps away from fabric and plastic.
- Growing media. Rockwool fibers and dust can irritate skin, eyes and throat; wet it before handling and wear gloves.
- Food hygiene. Wash your hands before handling plants and harvests, and rinse produce as you would any other.
Is it worth it?
Hydroponics lets you grow fresh greens and herbs indoors in winter, in small spaces and without weeds. Plants often grow quickly because water and nutrients are always available. In return it needs equipment, electricity, regular checking and some care with pH and nutrients, and a soil-based pot on a sunny windowsill is simpler for a few herbs. A kratky jar of lettuce is an inexpensive way to find out whether you enjoy it before buying a larger system.